Piano Instruction: Can we over-analyze a Bach fugue?

One of my Europe-based students bestowed the gift of J.S. Bach Fugue in C, BWV 952. He regarded it as a good springboard to learn the Baroque form. (The composition was not from the Well-Tempered Clavier, but it was one of the composer’s “LITTLE FUGUES.”)

For purposes of I.D., here’s Glenn Gould’s performance:

I had come to this FUGUE in a state of ignorance, though I’d been previously saturated with an excellent ONLINE analysis of WTC’s BWV 847 in C minor. (Jose Rodriguez Alvira)

http://www.teoria.com/articulos/analysis/BWV847/index.htm

And naturally, I expected to find an equivalent nit-picking probe of BWV 952 through a Google-driven search.

To my pleasant surprise, I found one produced by “Lance Walton,” an admitted “amateur,” that devoted a complete page to piecing out the Fugue, and in addition, had a PDF score link that led in scope to Alvira’s undertaking.

Only the standard FUGUE “vocabulary,” as I knew it, was modified, in places. (“Double Exposition” was a NEW term of art) And I didn’t see Counter-subject 1 and 2, or indications of Inversion, Augmentation etc. Well maybe they didn’t apply here. I was not prepared for any form departures.

Here’s the website and direct link to the PDF analysis.

http://www.stateofflow.com/journal/84/analysis-of-a-bach-fugue-bwv-952

The first three pages of six in living color:

Bach 942 revised p 1

bach 952 revised p 2

revised bwv952 p 3

I sent this Analysis to Jan Karman, a LINKED IN BACH GROUP member/composer/harpsichordist, for his response:

“Shirley, analysis is always arbitrary, and at any rate after the creation.

“The analysis is rarely the way a piece was composed.
One could carefully strip the theme from passing and changing notes and see
what remains.

“It’s also interesting to look at what types of changing note patterns Bach
is using, depending on which note the next accent would fall.

“In this rather simple fugue you may easily find the occurrences of the theme,
but also the sentences and even the motives, the latter of which Bach made
frequent use. E.g. there’s no mirrored or inverted theme, or complicated
modulations – the occurrences of the theme are mostly in neighboring keys.

“I think, as you stated in your previous mail, the flow in accordance
with the view and feeling of the performer, is very important, if not the only one
to hang on.”

Jan’s note was a wake up call. Though I knew myself to be obsessively preoccupied with form and structure as they applied to all the masterworks, and perhaps having been knee deep in BWV 847, I was looking for the same frame of reference in BWV 952: i.e. SUBJECT, COUNTER-SUBJECT 1 and 2, Inversions of, Augmentation, Diminution, and the rest.

To be initially immersed in a NEW landscape, without a specific mapping before I had embarked upon my journey with LITTLE FUGUE in C made me feel like I was walking in the wilderness. (Ridiculous, of course, since I’d been previously primed in my exploration of BWV 847 in C minor, WTC I)

Lance Walton’s own comments harmonized with Karman’s:

“Part of what this and other analyses have taught me is that Bach’s idea of a fugue was much richer than the textbooks. But that is always the case. We see the same attempts to systematize sonata form by theorists after the composers have been developing the ideas for a hundred years. I think it’s precisely the deviations from the theoretical standard that give us an insight into the thoughts of the masters.”

Elaine Comparone, world famous harpsichordist, chimed in:

“This kind of paper analysis may be useful for a “school fugue” but JS Bach fugues’ do not always fit into that kind of analysis. Basically, you want to HEAR the play of lines.” She’d made it a point to applaud Karman and Walton’s responses.

Here’s my second day READ of the Little Fugue in C with analytical commentary.

And what I had initially scribbled in the score: (excuse the illegible entries on page 1)

bwv952 fugue p 1

Bach bwv952 p2

***

When all is said and done, analyzing a Bach Fugue to the end of the earth is insufficient to render an aesthetically beautiful performance, though, not to be underestimated, are insights about how a composition is put together. A baby-step learning journey inevitably winds its way to a spiritual awakening through a sensitive process that has many creative ingredients.

Above all, we owe it to our students to be PREPARED to teach a composition if we expect our contributions to be of educational value.

LINKS: (as apply to Fugue in C minor BWV 847)

https://arioso7.wordpress.com/2012/12/22/revisiting-bachs-fugue-form-bwv-847-in-c-minor/

https://arioso7.wordpress.com/2012/03/02/piano-lesson-more-intensive-work-on-j-s-bach-fugue-in-c-minor-bwv-847-phrase-shaping-voice-balancing-and-formtheory-analysis/

https://arioso7.wordpress.com/2012/02/24/j-s-bach-fuguepiano-lesson-in-progress-bwv-847-in-c-minor-plus-aiden-cat-begs-for-affection-feeling-left-out-videos/

https://arioso7.wordpress.com/2011/12/16/piano-lesson-in-progress-fugue-in-c-minor-bwv-847-video/

OTHER:

http://www.harpsichord.org

JAN KARMAN

Website:
http://www.ganuenta.com

Music page:

http://www.ganuenta.com/comp.htm


Profile LinkedIn:

http://www.linkedin.com/profile/view?id=36996681&trk=tab_

About arioso7: Shirley Kirsten

International piano teacher by Skype, recording artist, composer, piano finder, freelance writer, film maker, story teller: Grad of the NYC HS of Performing Arts, Oberlin Conservatory, NYU (Master of Arts) Studies with Lillian Freundlich and Ena Bronstein; Master classes with Murray Perahia and Oxana Yablonskaya. Studios in BERKELEY and EL CERRITO, California; Member, Music Teachers Assoc. of California, MTAC; Distance learning and Skyped instruction with supplementary videos: SKYPE ID, shirleypiano1 Contact me at: shirley_kirsten@yahoo.com OR http://www.youtube.com/arioso7 or at FACEBOOK: Shirley Smith Kirsten, http://facebook.com /shirley.kirsten TWITTER: http://twitter.com/arioso7 Private fund-raising for non-profits as pianist--Public Speaking re: piano teaching and creative approaches
This entry was posted in Bach, Bach Little Fugue in C major BWV 952, Baroque form fugue, classissima, classissima.com, Elaine Comparone, fugue form analysis, J.S. Bach BWV 952 in C Major, J.S. Bach Fugue form, Jan Karman, Lance Walton, piano instruction, piano lessons, Shirley Kirsten, Shirley Smith Kirsten, Theory, Theory and piano lessons, whole body listening, whole body music listening, word press, word press.com, wordpress, wordpress.com, you tube, you tube video, you tube.com, yout tube, youtube.com and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Piano Instruction: Can we over-analyze a Bach fugue?

  1. Oh my, your blog is marvelous! Thank you, thank you!

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s